Dreaming About an Old Friendship: The Feelings We Pretend We’ve Outgrown
- TheSubtle.Mind
- Feb 26
- 2 min read
In the dream, I wasn’t myself.
I was standing under bright studio lights, the kind that hum softly overhead like trapped stars. Rows of seats stretched out in front of me, filled with faceless people clapping too loud, laughing too easily. Everything felt staged, rehearsed, too colorful to be real.
Someone handed me a stack of letters tied with silver string.
“From the viewers,” they said.
Like I had agreed to read strangers’ hearts out loud.
One by one, we opened them.
Some were silly. Some dramatic. Some written in glitter ink like confessions disguised as jokes.
Then one slipped into my hands — heavier than the rest.
The paper was thick. Creased. Like it had been folded and unfolded a hundred times.
It read:
There’s someone I used to know. We don’t speak anymore. But every time I see them, I roll my eyes like it doesn’t matter. Like they don’t matter. Like I’m above it.
The audience laughed softly, like it was petty, like it was small.
But my chest tightened.
Because suddenly I wasn’t on a stage anymore.
I was in a parking lot.
Late afternoon light. Asphalt warm. Air still.
And there it was.
A familiar car.
The kind you recognize before you even consciously register why.
My stomach dropped the way it used to.
I remember pretending not to look — but looking anyway.
Making a face without meaning to. A small twist of the mouth. A quiet scoff.
Like if I could make them smaller in my expression, the history between us would shrink too.
Like indifference could erase memory.
Back in the dream, the letter trembled in my hands.
The words began rearranging themselves.
If I’m truly over it, it asked, why does my body still react first?
The studio got quieter.
The lights dimmed.
The laughter track disappeared.
Because it wasn’t about them at all.
It was about me.
About how we pretend we don’t care when something once meant everything.
How we call it “growth” when sometimes it’s just avoidance dressed up as pride.
How rolling our eyes is easier than admitting: that hurt me more than I thought.
The stack of letters fell away.
The set dissolved.
And I woke up with the strangest realization —
Sometimes the dreams that feel the smallest are just the softest places we’re still tender.
Reflection
Maybe we don’t make those faces because we’re above the past.
Maybe we make them because some part of us never got closure.
Because the heart remembers what the mind tries to downplay.
Because “I’m over it” and “it didn’t matter” are not always the same thing.
Closing Line
Have you ever caught yourself pretending not to care about someone your heart clearly hasn’t forgotten yet?
Comments